I enlisted the help of our 4 year old son. He joined me as we went through everything and put in a basket the things we wanted to "give to someone else to play with." Now, I won't lie and say that I didn't go back during nap time and weed some more things out. Overall, I was so impressed with our little guy. We even talked about how we don't need multiples of one item i.e. 5 bags or 15 bears (pretty sure our stuffed animal count set a world record). He was able to look and choose which one he liked best. He is getting so big! (That is a post for another time...). So when we were all said and done, 9 trash bags were shoved into my car to be taken to a local homeless shelter and 4 more were set aside and listed for sale on our local Buy/Sell/Trade site (in 2 days I have made about $150!).
All the remaining toys were things that my children love to play with. Other items, they hadn't played with because I hadn't kept them up with batteries or kept the pieces together. Everything has a place and is in great condition. When we were done, we were able to downsize some of the oversized furniture we had to accommodate everything with other pieces we already owned. The end result is nothing short of amazing! And it is SO much easier for the boys to help put away their toys at the end of the night. I feel like the boys have been happier playing because they have less to chose from, can find what they are looking for easily, and are not mindlessly dumping things everywhere. It is a huge win for all of us. And, this is just the beginning (I feel like I should insert evil laugh here).